Are Stiletto Hammers Worth The Hefty Price Tag? Here's What Buyers Are Saying

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

When buying tools, you want them to be durable and get the job done. Some brands are classic and reliable, but others, like Stiletto, try to innovate tools and make them easier to use, more durable, multifunctional, or otherwise better than traditional options. However, these features come at a steep cost. For example, while a typical new hammer, one of the tools every homeowner should have, can be bought for as low as $10, the 15-ounce TiBone milled face with curved handle hammer by Stiletto costs $239 from Amazon. The price may be high, but the product has an average review of 4.5 stars out of 5, with similarly positive ratings found at other retailers. If you are looking for a lightweight, balanced hammer that is made of titanium but can hit like steel, then a Stiletto hammer may be worth the investment for you.

The big draw of Stiletto hammers is the titanium material. Rather than steel, these hammers are made from titanium, which makes them 45% lighter than traditional hammers while still being strong and durable. At the time of writing, there are 20 varieties of hammers on Stiletto's website. There are titanium, fiberglass, and hickory handle options, and weights range between 10 and 16 ounces. Prices vary depending on the handle and size you choose. You can also choose either a milled or smooth face. While many reviewers seem to think this hammer is worth buying, some reviewers point out potential drawbacks you may want to know about before you make the investment. 

Before purchasing such an expensive tool, it is good to know how other users feel about it. For Stiletto hammers, the outlook seems good. Reviewers of the 15-ounce TiBone milled face with curved handle hammer on Home Depot overwhelmingly rated the product 5 stars out of 5 stars. One common theme among the 5-star reviews on Home Depot's website is related to reduced arm fatigue and pain when using a Stiletto hammer. One Home Depot reviewer wrote, "The first thing I noticed was how light weight it is. This reduced weight was appreciated when I realized how much less fatigue I experienced." Another shared their positive experience, stating, "I really don't have elbow pain after using it all day. It makes that much of a difference." Regarding durability, one user shares that their Stiletto hammer has "taken some serious falls and abuse, but has taken it well. The handle is still perfect and there's no damage in the claw." Overall, the majority of the reviews praise the hammer's light weight, power, and durability. However, there are some buyers who have negative experiences to discuss.

Of the couple of negative reviews about the product itself, most are about durability. For example, one person complained that their "claws look like they been abused for years" after fewer than two months of use. Another worry about the hammers is their limited warranty. One buyer, who rated the hammer 4 stars, critiqued, "So I'm dropping one star from the review due to the short warranty given with this hammer; I think a year is much too short for this level of tool."

If you have figured out what to know before you buy a hammer, know your budget, and like the sound of the positive reviews on the Stiletto hammers, then they may be the perfect choice for you. When it comes to choosing between the products, it helps to have an understanding of which of their hammers are most popular. All of the Stiletto hammer products on Home Depot's website, except for one (the 15-ounce TiBone milled face with curved handle hammer with blue replacement grip), are rated about 4.1 stars or higher, so it is hard to go wrong when choosing among the products. The highest rated product is the 10 oz. Titanium Smooth Face Hammer with 14 1/2 in. Curved Hickory Handle. This product has a 4.7-star rating and over 200 reviews. It is also one of the more affordable Stiletto options, costing about $120. If you like a wooden handle on a hammer, then this could be a good option.

Overall, with high ratings and lots of praise from individual buyers, it seems that reviewers find that Stiletto hammers are worth their expensive price, especially for anyone dealing with fatigue or arm pain. Whether you choose a Stiletto hammer or not, once you have your new hammer, do not forget to learn how to choose the perfect hammer for the job for any project you are working on so that you can optimize the use of your tools.