The Overall Best Lawn Fertilizer Brand, According To Customer Reviews

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

If you want a lawn that's lush, green, and free of weeds, you should know the right type of grass to plant (and the few to avoid). How often you mow the grass and what length you cut it is also an important step in meeting your goals. One key factor for a healthy lawn is to ensure your soil is nourished. And although there are a whole bunch of natural ingredients that can provide your lawn with the nutrients it needs, applying them individually can be complicated. Many people find it easier to simply buy a single, balanced fertilizer they can purchase at a local or online retailer. 

There are plenty of different products to choose from in both pellet and liquid form, and while you could try cherry-picking the best for each situation, it is probably a good idea to stick to a single, reliable brand. But which one? The leading contenders, those that are featured regularly in online surveys of the best lawn fertilizers, are Espoma, Milorganite, and Simple Lawn Solutions. However, the one that rises to the top the most often, in numerous different categories, is Scotts. 

Scotts produces a wide range of lawn fertilizers for general purpose use, new grass, winter preparation, dealing with dandelions, etc. Thousands of customers at Amazon, Home Depot, and Lowe's give these products excellent ratings. Although an individual product from a competitor may receive a similar score, no other lawn fertilizer brand can consistently match the number of satisfied customers or the number of stars that Scotts receives. Comments like "great products" and "Scotts is the best" are typical of the level of positive feedback. "Works well and a good value," wrote one happy customer, while another said, "Greened up my lawn and made it healthy and lush again." More than one reviewer had reported using the brand for ten years or more. There can't be a better recommendation than that.

Although complaints are rare, a few people reported burned grass, which is why it is important to follow the application instructions carefully. There were also those who were disappointed with the level of weed control, but as one happy customer pointed out, some of the Scott's products have weed killer included, and some do not. That's why you should always read the label. The range of their fertilizer products is extensive, allowing customers to choose one that targets specific issues. It's this combination of variety, and the reliable results delivered, that make Scotts the best overall lawn fertilizer brand.

There are numerous sources that rate the best natural fertilizer for your lawn, the best liquid lawn feed, or the best lawn fertilizer for controlling weeds, for example. However, our challenge was to pick the best overall brand — not a single product.

We did this in two ways. First, we checked a half dozen of the most popular independent online sources to see which brands cropped up regularly and which offered a variety of different solutions for varied lawn care challenges. Then we checked buyer feedback at several major retailers. This gave us real-world customer reviews that allowed us to build a picture of the best lawn fertilizer brand.