Butler Vs Belfast Sink: What's The Difference? (& Which Is Best For Your Kitchen)

Planning a kitchen renovation or update may have you exploring new sinks that provide function and style. While there are many beautiful kitchen sink ideas to transform your space, two classic options that you may come across are Butler and Belfast style sinks. At just a glance, they look similar. They are large, rectangular in shape, and their farmhouse-style basins in the front provide a bold statement. However, in digging a little deeper you'll find that the features and practicality of each sink have some key differences. Considerations in size, depth, and usage come into play. Belfast sinks are usually much deeper and have an overflow at the top of the basin, while Butler sink styles don't have an overflow and are less deep.

These overflow abilities between the Belfast and Butler sinks are a primary difference to consider. Belfast sinks have a weir overflow, or a small opening near the top of the basin that prevents any water from spilling over the front or sides. They are deeper and more narrow to fit many large pots and pans, or big batches of dishes. Traditional butler sinks lack an overflow, which can provide a cleaner, more sleek and modern style that is very similar to the farmhouse sink. However, if you have a larger family or tend to use the sink more often, a Belfast sink may be the ticket – holding more water with its deeper bowl.

Breaking down the two sink types further involves looking at the size in your space, and how well it works with your kitchen design. The Butler sink style can be ideal for more contemporary kitchens, emphasizing functionality and aesthetics. These sinks can be more practical in the kitchen for everyday tasks and lighter use. It's a more streamlined style, and the slightly lengthier look can visually broaden your kitchen, blending in with your cabinetry. It works well with modern, farmhouse and transitional designs. It can also be an excellent type of sink to install in your Hamptons-style kitchen. Although they come in several sizes, Butler sinks are often shallower and longer, which can make reaching the basin easier for homeowners.  

The Belfast sink works well in larger, more spacious kitchens, handling more water and usage. However, this also means it takes up more space in the cabinet underneath, and its heavy design may require extra supports. The overflow protection is key so you don't have to be as cautious when filling the sink. The deeper bowl size can provide a stunning statement. Also, if you hand-wash more often or don't own a dishwasher, it's an excellent upgrade choice due to its spacious capacity. It complements designs with cottage, country, or traditional styles, and  can also be a welcome addition to your victorian-style home. The Belfast sink is often more favored for kitchens due to the overflow feature and practical functionality.