We Ranked The 16 Best Memory Foam Mattresses By Customer Reviews

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Memory foam mattresses are affordable and easy to set-up. Those attributes have made them a go-to option when it's time to replace your mattress. They arrive rolled up in a box at your door, but after unpacking, the mattress will be fully expanded in about 24 to 72 hours. Delivery and set-up are the easy part, but choosing the best mattress can be more tricky. Factors like your sleeping style, budget, and firmness preference need to be considered.

There's no single best mattress for everyone, but we've considered the most popular mattresses from top retailers. All of our picks have over 1,000 reviews and a minimum 4-star rating. By comparing the best memory foam mattresses based on customer reviews, you can find the one that will give you a sweet night of sleep.

The Lucid 10-Inch Memory Foam Mattress is a low-profile pick that costs less than $350 for a queen. You can pick the softness you need, from firm to plush, but some reviewers say the mattress skews to the firm side. "It is extremely firm rather than medium plush as advertised. I have two Nectar mattresses which are medium firm and this one is more firm in comparison," says one reviewer.

With 53,592 reviews on Amazon and a 4.4-star rating, this is a popular basic, budget memory foam mattress. If you need a thin mattress for a Murphy or trundle bed, this option may work. Just know that problems with expansion have been noted by some reviewers.

At 12 inches in height, the Nectar Classic is a thicker mattress than the Lucid, leading to its higher ranking. The extra cushion provides plushness without losing support. One Amazon reviewer says, "I'm a side sleeper and before I would wake up with my hips hurting and my shoulders killing me. When you lay on it, you're sinking just enough for it to mold around you but that's it—it's not hard, it's not soft." 

The Nectar Classic has earned a 4.3-star rating based on 8,797 Amazon reviews. Mattress comfort is subjective, but it's worth knowing this mattress has been endorsed by the American Chiropractic Association. You can take advantage of a 365-night sleep trial to see if the mattress is the right fit for your sleeping style. 

The Novilla 12-inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress offers a similar cushy depth to the Nectar Classic, but uses gel-infused memory foam as an upgrade. The brand claims that this accomplishes two purposes: cooling and pressure relief. One satisfied sleeper says, "Quality materials, no weird smells out of the box, and it stays cool throughout the night." This mattress costs $300 for a queen, which is less than half the cost of the Nectar Classic.

This pick has over 30,000 reviews on Amazon and a 4.4-star rating. Adding credibility to its cooling claims are reviews like this one: "Its gel-infused memory foam helps regulate temperature, keeping you cool throughout the night while relieving pressure on your shoulders and hips." The same reviewer adds that the mattress also keeps you from noticing movement on the other side of the bed. 

Reaching a height of 14 inches, the Classic Brands Cool Gel Chill Memory Foam Mattress is designed to be ultra plush without losing support. It adds an extra 2 inches of memory foam compared to the 12-inch Nectar Classic. Plus, this mattress has a gel-infused middle layer of foam, while the similarly-plush Novilla Gel Memory Foam Mattress only adds gel particles to the top layer. 

At Amazon, this mattress has a 4.4-star rating from over 60,000 reviews. Regarding the performance of its cooling properties, reviewers are impressed. "The one feature that my previous memory foam mattress lacked was the cooling ventilated gel. I wasn't sure how it would work but I am really pleased to say that the experience of sleeping on this mattress was entirely different than traditional memory foam. The first thing I noticed was how cool it stays and not just initially, but all night," says one reviewer.

The Tuft & Needle Original 10-inch Mattress may not be the plushest mattress of the bunch, but this option gives a firm, supportive sleeping surface, according to customers. It stands out compared to the previous memory foam mattresses because it's Greenguard Gold certified. This means it meets low emission standards for more than 360 VOCs and chemicals. Like other mattresses, this pick also utilizes CertiPur-certified foam, but it's worth noting that achieving Greenguard Gold certification is more rigorous and fewer products carry this distinction.

On Wayfair, this mattress earns a 4.6-star rating based on over 25,500 reviews. As far as the mattress emitting less odor, many reviewers say that there is little to no smell after unpacking it. One reviewer says, "Great mattress in a box. Other ones smell when opening...which this one did not." 

The Purple Gel Memory Foam Mattress stands out compared to the Tuft & Needle mattress, and other all-foam picks we've discussed, because it uses a polymer grid for the sleeping surface. On top of 7.5 inches of layered foam is the 2-inch GelFlex grid layer. The hype about the Purple Mattress centers around this GelFlex layer, which claims to disperse heat and also flex for pressure point relief.

At Wayfair, this mattress has garnered over 28,600 reviews and a 4.4 star rating. The mattress is only offered as medium-firm. Regarding the ability of the mattress to provide support without pressure, here's what one buyer says, "The mattress gives way easily to pressure points but remains firm and supportive everywhere else. The only complaint is that you can't use regular sheets with it. For best results, you should use Purple's stretchy sheets. Unfortunately those sheets are very expensive." It's true that the brand points out that sheets that are too tight can minimize the benefit of sleeping on the adaptive GelFlex grid.

The Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-ProAdapt Mattress is another memory foam mattress alternative. Unlike the Purple Essential, the TEMPUR-ProAdapt is an all-foam mattress. But instead of conventional memory foam, this mattress utilizes the brand's TEMPUR-Material, which has an open-cell structure that responds to pressure, body weight, and heat. If you're trying to decide if a Tempur-Pedic mattress is right for you, know that you'll be in for a bit of a break-in period. After that, expect a mattress that is simultaneously soft and supportive. "After a few nights of breaking in, was a perfect feel. Firmly supports each curve of the body. Just the right amount of firmness," says one Wayfair reviewer.

Based on over 2,500 reviews at Wayfair, this mattress has a 4.5-star rating. In addition to a break-in period, the biggest tradeoff is a steep price. The TEMPUR-ProAdapt costs $3,199 for a queen-size. It's backed by a 10-year warranty period. In addition, some reviewers say that the mattress holds heat, so that's something to consider if you're a warm sleeper.

Like the TEMPUR-Pro Adapt Mattress, the Tuft & Needle Mint 12-inch Mattress uses proprietary foam to provide squishy support without causing excessive sink. There's a Flex foam layer that is meant to be breathable and responsive to your body weight and position. A Release foam layer is ventilated for cooling and is designed to relieve pressure points. These advantages make the Tuft & Needle a better option for people that sleep hot or that have a smaller budget for a foam mattress. The queen-size mattress has a 10-year warranty and retails for $1,295, compared to over $3,000 for the TEMPUR-Pro Adapt.

At Home Depot, this mattress has over 14,100 reviews with a 4.6-star rating. After sleeping on it, one Home Depot reviewer describes the experience, "The foam hugs you like it's been waiting your whole life. My spine, once a bag of angry Rice Krispies, now rests like royalty. It's firm yet forgiving, cool as a mountain breeze, and somehow knows exactly where I need support."

The GhostBed Essential Series is a highly-rated firm mattress with a 20-year warranty — twice the coverage of the TEMPUR-Pro Adapt or the Tuft & Needle Mint. Rather than a plush, sinking feeling, this memory foam mattress has enough give to ease pressure points, but offers firm support. A firm mattress is often preferred by heavier people or those that sleep on their back or stomach. To provide the needed support, GhostBed designed this mattress with a 7-inch layer of high-density base foam, topped by 2 1/2 inches of the brand's flex foam. For pressure relief and light give, the top layer is 1 1/2 inches of gel-infused memory foam.

Based on over 8,900 reviews at Home Depot, this GhostBed mattress has a 4.6-star rating. While some comments indicate that the mattress holds heat, most reviewers have positive things to say. One buyer says, "I am a very heavy male, 380lbs, this bed holds up and does not sink too much. My wife who is on the smaller side had been having back trouble. After a month in this bed her back problem has disappeared. The only thing I would say is that it isn't as cooling as I thought it would be, it is much better than our pillow top mattress."

With lifetime warranty coverage, the DreamCloud Classic Memory Foam Mattress is meant to be long-lasting. If the mattress starts to sag or indents, the company will repair or replace it. These warranty terms are even better than the 20-year warranty offered by GhostBed. It also offsets concerns over durability, which is one of the biggest downsides to bed-in-a-box mattresses. But warranty terms mean very little if you don't find the mattress comfortable. This memory foam mattress has an extra-firm feel, according to the brand. At the same time, reviewers say that it does conform well to the body and facilitates a good night of rest.

On DreamCloud's website, the mattress has over 9,300 reviews and a 4.6-star rating. Consistently, reviewers describe the mattress as firm, but not too hard. Take it from this reviewer: "I have lower back and shoulder pain, so I took a chance, and this mattress is comfortable, has some give, but provides needed support, and I sleep well and wake up with no pain."

The Sealy Cool 12-inch Memory Foam Mattress is softer in comparison to the firm feel of the DreamCloud or GhostBed Essential mattresses. Described as having a medium firmness, the 12-inch thick mattress has two layers of foam. The base layer is support foam topped by gel-infused memory foam. The result is a mattress that one reviewer describes like this, "Not firm, not soft, just perfectly medium."

With over 10,000 reviews on Wayfair, this mattress has earned a 4.7-star rating. Based on the reviews, the mattress is a good middle-ground for couples that might have differing preferences for mattress firmness. As a case in point, one reviewer says, "I like a softer mattress while my husband likes a firm one. We are both happy with this mattress. We tried so many different mattresses and toppers that failed to be comfortable for both of us." The same reviewer also points out that this mattress doesn't hold heat, saying, "Plus, it really stays a nice temperature. It does not cook us."

The Alwyn Home Gel Memory Foam Mattress diversifies its foam layers in comparison to the Sealy Cool Memory Foam Mattress. After the base foam layer, this mattress uses a layer of wave-cut support foam that is intended to facilitate airflow. Topping that layer is a gel-infused memory foam for cooling purposes. The mattress is encased in an OEKO-TEX certified knit cover. Compared to some other memory foam mattresses on this list, there's a wide range of thicknesses available for this mattress, ranging from a slim 5-inch pick to a plush 14-inch option.

Based on the over 2,700 Wayfair reviews for this mattress, it has a 4.7-star rating. The mattress is frequently described as very comfortable. One reviewer had this to say: "Less bulky than a typical foam mattress but still provides the comfort you would expect from a full-thickness mattress. Liked it so much we purchased two others in different sizes."

The Casper Element is a memory foam mattress with a 10-inch height. It stands out for its medium firmness and reviewers say that it's especially great for back or side sleepers. That's not a surprise, since memory foam mattresses might be your best option if you're a side sleeper, thanks to the gentle give of the foam. One Home Depot reviewer who was initially skeptical says, "I was worried about lower back support. 175lbs. Support is great. I mainly sleep back and side that this one nails!"

This mattress has overwhelmingly positive reviews, including a 4.8-star rating based on 2,570 reviews at Home Depot. The stellar support of this mattress comes from the 6.5-inch layer of base foam and a top 3-inch layer of perforated foam for air flow circulation. The top layer of perforated foam isn't a feature found on the Alwyn Home Mattress. 

Slumber Solutions Gel Memory Foam Mattress has a reputation for being supremely comfy and comes in thicker mattress heights than the Casper Element. In addition to a 10-inch height option, you can add more inches of support foam by opting for the 12- or 14-inch thick version of this mattress. Regardless of the depth, three layers of foam make up this medium firmness mattress. The top layer is infused with gel, which the brand says dissipates body heat.

At Wayfair, this mattress has 5,420 reviews resulting in a 4.7-star rating. If you want a plush memory foam mattress, the fact that 81% of this mattress's reviews are 5-star ratings is a good sign. And while some mattresses have break-in periods, that's not always the case with this option. People describe being very satisfied with the comfort of this mattress right away. "Night 3 and we're very happy! I know it's early, but both my husband and I have been impressed that neither one of us has woken up during the middle of the night on this mattress."

The most popular memory foam mattresses should all be comfortable — that's a given. But at the top of the list, you'll find other features. In the case of the Wayfair Sleep Memory Foam Mattress, the mattress claims to reduce odors and improve freshness. The top layer of the 10-inch thick mattress is infused with green tea for controlling odors. Underneath, a layer of comfort foam provides pressure relief, while the bottom layer of base foam gives durability and support. Notably, many reviewers agree that this mattress doesn't have the usual chemical odor of bed-in-a-box mattresses. Says one Wayfair reviewer, "This is a great quality bed for the price. Delivered quickly and does not smell of fumes."

This mattress has racked up an impressive over 64,000 reviews and a 4.7-star rating. Aside from the lack of smell after unboxing, a frequent point of praise is the mattress' comfort and temperature-regulation properties. Here's what one happy reviewer had to say, "The mattress is a great value. It's very comfortable and does not sink when I lay on it. It's firm yet soft. I do not overheat on this mattress."

The ComforPedic Loft Mattress from Beautyrest takes the top spot of the best memory foam mattresses. This firm option is renowned by customers for being ultra comfortable and an excellent value for the price. It combines attributes of previous picks into one highly-rated mattress. The specific highlights include a gel-infused top layer of memory foam for cooling and the choice of a 10-, 12-, or 14-inch thickness to suit your preference. It's also available in specialty sizes like Twin XL for a dorm room, or a California King for sleepers that like a lot of extra room.

There are over 6,400 reviews for this mattress with an overall rating of 4.7 stars. Impressively, nearly 83% are 5-star ratings — the highest of any mattress on our list. Reviewers have plenty of good things to say about the mattress' firm, but comfortable, feel. As an example, this satisfied buyer says, "Super comfortable and supportive mattress. Firm but not hard, and great for a full night's sleep. Excellent quality for the price — highly recommend!"

To find the best memory foam mattresses, we compared picks from popular retailers. We included memory foam mattresses of different thicknesses and firmness levels to address a range of sleeping styles. We looked at the total number of reviews and only included mattresses with at least 1,000 reviews and a 4.0-star or better rating. We compared each mattress to find its strengths and weaknesses in comparison to other available options.