Consumer Reports Names The Highest-Rated Mid-Size Gas Grill In 2026

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Choosing the right gas grill is harder than it sounds. There are a ton of options out there with various features, pros, and cons, but Consumer Reports can help you make an informed decision. CR tests and compares various consumer products, including gas grills, and according to its ratings, the Napoleon Rogue PRO 425 3-Burner Propane Gas Grill was the highest-rated mid-size gas grill model. It not only earned top scores in cooking but also performed well in terms of reliability and owner satisfaction in Consumer Reports' review.

Currently, you can get it for $971 from Home Depot, and it comes in two finishes, black and stainless steel. It is a three-burner propane grill with an additional infrared side burner, as well as coated cast-iron cooking grids. It also features Napoleon's Jetfire ignition system, which allows users to light burners without a battery. Other than that, the grill has folding side shelves and utensil hooks, and there is even an integrated bottle opener. Performance-wise, the grill can reach a temperature of 400 degrees Fahrenheit in just about four minutes, and its main burners can deliver heating power up to 42,000 BTUs.

Consumer Reports gave the grill perfect scores in temperature range and indirect cooking (a test that looks at how evenly a grill heats food that's not directly touching the flame), as well as a nearly perfect score for preheating and overall heat distribution. That said, the grill only has a main cooking area of about 371 square inches. So, if you are cooking for a large group, it might not suffice; you might want to look into other top grill brands before making the purchase.

Home Depot buyer feedback gives Napoleon Rogue PRO 425 Propane Gas Grill a more complicated real-world picture. It currently has about 100 ratings and an overall score just below 4 stars. While many customers have left positive reviews, a noticeable number of lower reviews, including a number of 1-star reviews, have been posted as well. Now, customer feedback does not erase the grill's strong Consumer Reports scores, but it is still worth keeping in mind before you buy a new grill for your home.

A deeper look into the reviews reveals that buyers generally appreciate the build quality and stainless-steel construction of the grill. Furthermore, they seem satisfied with its strong heat control, even heat distribution, and searing with the infrared side burner. The infrared side burner has also been a standout for multiple buyers. Many have said that it produces excellent searing results on steaks and fillets in just a few minutes. Where the grill gets criticism, though, is in the assembly and delivery experience.

Buyers report the build takes from two to even five hours to assemble, and several have flagged the included instructions as too vague for a product of this complexity. Multiple shoppers also reported receiving damaged units. In fact, one buyer even said, "My recommendation is not to purchase this grill if it requires shipping as damage can be hidden. Only purchase the grill if you can inspect the condition before purchasing." But no matter where you get it, online or in person, make sure you know how to keep your grill safe and clean after purchase as well.