It Was Produced For A Year In The '50s — The Rare Glass Pitcher Worth Hunting For At Thrift Stores

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Calling all thrifting enthusiasts, there's a rare type of vintage glassware to keep on your radar: the Fenton Cranberry Opalescent 'Coin Dot' water pitcher. The specific version in question was produced only between 1955 and 1956 and first appeared in the Fenton Art Glass 50th anniversary catalog. While there are a bunch of similar vintage Fenton glass products still available in secondhand shops and on sites like eBay, this specific variation is especially sought after due to its short production run and eye-catching mid-century flair. Pricing varies by seller, but based on the prices other Fenton pitchers sell for, the 1955-56 opalescent coin dot model could be worth upwards of hundreds of dollars.

The pitcher itself features cranberry-colored glass, achieved by mixing in real gold during the creation process. A white coin dot pattern pops against the reddish-pink glass, giving it a strawberry-like appearance. The opening has a distinct pink ruffled design that sets it apart from other Fenton cranberry pitchers without the frilled edges. This retro art piece features a vertically ribbed handle. There's also an alternative configuration with all the same features, except the coin dots are reddish-pink and the pitcher itself is milky white. While it's practically identical in design, its coloration and honeycomb pattern give it away.

Fenton produced similar coin dot pitchers, vases, and other glassware between 1947 and 1964 and then again in the 1980s, making it easy to mistake alternate products or reproductions for the rare 1955-56 model. So how can you tell if you've found the actual thing? The first authenticity test to try is to look for a Fenton engraving on the bottom of the pitcher. If it's blank, that's a good thing! The company didn't start adding its label until the 1970s and 1980s. If there is a label, it likely means it was made later when Fenton brought back some of its original designs.

The size of the pitcher can also help determine if it's the coin dot, or another Fenton pitcher, or a different brand with a similar ruffled lip detail. This is especially important when searching online, as the elegant vintage glassware brand sold smaller pitchers meant for creamer. Reports vary, but the original 1955 catalog lists the jug holding 70 ounces. So make sure to verify the liquid capacity before making a purchase. Another way to ensure the product is the rare version is to look at the pattern. The pitcher should have small coin-shape dots that are a different color from the base. The coin dot pitcher is not to be confused with other Fenton pitchers or remakes that have large coin dots, textured hobnail patterns, heart shapes, or indented polka dots.