The Once-Popular Design Trend HGTV's Christina Haack Just Can't Get Behind

We've all had those moments where we look back at past design trends and cringe knowing we've participated in them. There are some choices that even the biggest stars refuse to participate in whether or not they reappear in the trend forecast. That said, if you want your home to have that HGTV star charm like Christina Haack's, there are plenty of ways to nail her design aesthetic — just be sure to steer clear of one particular style. While Haack loves to experiment with various kinds of decor looks, the one previously reigning trend she can't get behind is Tuscan style. 

You might remember Tuscan style from the mid-2000s, when almost every home embraced the plaster walls, deep warm tones, and overly opulent details associated with this look. It's been years since the style faded but long enough for some homeowners who seek a nostalgic comfort to start slowly bringing the look back into relevancy. However, if you want to know which design trends are still in and which are out, according to Haack, she'd be sure to say that the Tuscan look is still out. The good news is that, if you're captured by the cozy charm this style holds, there are ways you can bring it into the modern day in a way that Haack herself might even approve of.

In today's modern world, homeowners are seeking to find a balance between overly extravagant and sometimes too minimalistic design approaches. That's why we're seeing more looks like the organic modern aesthetic rise in popularity, which harmonizes rich textures and natural styles for a subtly stylish feel. Tuscan style, however, tends to stray from subtlety, overly emphasizing Italian-inspired and Old World designs in a way that often lands more tacky than tasteful. When asked which trend she'd be happy to never participate in again, Christina Haack told Realtor.com, "that heavy Tuscan [style]. Like the travertine everywhere — and trust me, I used to do it in the early 2000s — I'm not super into that, all the browns, the heavy rugs, and all those things." While interest in bringing back some elements of the Tuscan style is starting to come back, jumping full-force into these elements could leave your home looking outdated. 

Although, there are advantages to the Tuscan style which may align with current trends and decor. For instance, the style uses many natural elements like stone and wood architecture details which reflects the "bringing the outdoors in" approach that has been a common thread through popular decor styles in 2025. In the same sense, the aesthetic has a strong use of earth tones, specifically warm, earthy hues, which are not only trendy but also bring a cozy feel into the home. These characteristics, as well as other elements from Tuscan style like statement textiles, vintage finishes, and elegant details, can be a huge asset to your home when used thoughtfully.

Christina Haack's distaste for the Tuscan style trend comes from the "heavy" elements associated with its mid-2000s heyday, but that doesn't mean the look is a lost cause for every home. The Tuscan look of the past often uses darker colors like chocolate brown, deep reds, or dark stained wood cabinets. To make this style feel more current, take a softer approach with light neutrals like off-white and beige shades that will open up the space for an airer, authentically European feel. If you want to get HGTV star Christina Haack's look in your home, try elevating outdated Tuscan decor with neutral color palettes and beachy tones while saving those darker features for spaces where you want to add some drama.

The hardware in Tuscan-style homes can often feel overly intricate and traditional, which can look a bit too over-the-top in today's subtle design trends. Instead of using complex hardware and fixtures, opt for sleeker styles and shapes. You can still enjoy the antique look of this trend by using hardware in chic brass or oil-rubbed bronze materials — this offers some shine and style in a way that stands out without being too intense. Similar to hardware, early 2000s Tuscan-style furniture can also be deemed overly detailed. Instead, modern Tuscan design embraces furniture with simpler lines, lighter wood finishes, and warm, inviting fabrics over traditional tufted pieces. The key is to focus on simplifying and brightening up the classic style.